
Asset class and market access still drive conversion complexity. Under the IRS’s September 2026 guidance on 351 exchanges, so does strategy fit: the closer the contributed portfolio is to what the ETF will hold, the more straightforward the conversion.
We first wrote this piece in early 2024, when the main question managers asked about conversions were operational: how hard will it be to move this strategy into an ETF? That question hasn't gone away. But on September 28, Treasury and the IRS released Rev. Rul. 2026-20 and Notice 2026-62, and anyone converting existing managed assets, like a private fund, liquid family office holdings, or SMA assets through a 351 exchange now has a second question sitting alongside the first. Does the portfolio going into the ETF match the ETF’s investment strategy?
The Simplest Path
On the operational side, not much has changed. Domestic, long-only equity strategies are still generally the most straightforward to convert, and a fund-of-funds built from other ETFs usually isn't far behind.
The 351 guidance adds another way of thinking about "simple." The ruling targets conversions where contributed securities are redeemed out under a prearranged plan shortly after launch, leaving the investor in a materially different portfolio. The Notice, for its part, doesn't address seeding a fund with assets consistent with its investment thesis that are intended and expected to be retained. Read together, the two put a premium on continuity.
In our experience, the conversions that come together most cleanly tend to involve a model-driven strategy, where client accounts hold close to the same names at close to the same weights. Turnover is modest. Legacy positions and client-specific restrictions are limited, or can be resolved before launch rather than after. And each contributor's holdings are already diversified enough to meet the 25% and 5/50 test under Section 351(e), a requirement for transfers to an investment company that long predates the new guidance.
Strategies further from that profile aren't off the table, but they usually take more work up front. A high-dispersion SMA book, where accounts have drifted apart over the years or carry a long tail of positions the model wouldn't buy today, calls for careful decisions about what goes into the contributed basket. Concentrated portfolios raise a different issue: related Treasury regulations already prevent the practice of “stuffing” to achieve diversification, and the Notice separately flags exchange-fund structures that pool concentrated positions in a partnership before rolling them into an ETF.
Higher-turnover strategies deserve a word as well. Nothing in the guidance treats normal trading as a problem; the ruling is aimed at a prearranged repositioning, not at a manager doing what the strategy has always done. Still, the guidance sets no holding period and no turnover threshold, so a manager whose process naturally trades a lot should expect to document that pattern carefully from the first day.
Different Markets, Different Rules
International strategies remain more involved. U.S. ETFs that hold foreign securities hold them in foreign custody, and some foreign markets, including many emerging markets, don't permit in-kind delivery of securities, so the ability to transact in-kind may be limited. Transaction taxes and fees on transferring certain foreign securities add another layer, as can the use of margin.
With fixed income, lot sizes still need attention, both for building creation baskets and for working out how a contributed bond portfolio maps onto the fund.
Strategies with commodity or digital asset exposure now call for extra care. The Notice flags funds that use in-kind redemptions to keep gains on assets that don't generate qualifying RIC income, such as commodities, digital assets or grantor trusts holding them, out of the 90% income test. That doesn't rule these strategies out, but the structuring questions are more involved than they were a year ago.
Planning the Conversion
Every conversion still turns on the specifics of the strategy, and the guidance hasn't settled everything. Comments are due October 28, more guidance may follow, and the agencies have said it could apply retroactively. In the meantime, the practical lesson is to do more of the work before launch: settle what goes into the basket, write down why the fund holds what it holds, and bring tax counsel in early.
If you're weighing a conversion, we're glad to talk through how these factors apply to your strategy. Contact us here.
The information provided herein does not constitute tax, legal or accounting advice. ETC does not provide legal, financial, accounting or tax advice.
Exchange Traded Concepts, LLC (“ETC”) is an SEC Registered Investment Adviser. ETC presently offers two lines of business, the first being the provision of white-label ETF services, that include investment advisory and administrative platform services, and the second is offering its portfolio management services on a stand-alone basis to other advisers managing funds that have a need for a specialized trading sub-adviser familiar with and skilled in trading on behalf of an ETF and other investment vehicles. ETC provides the trust, board, and decades of experience to offer asset managers (hedge, SMAs, mutual) and others an efficient, cost-effective means to leverage the benefits of the ETF wrapper. ETC’s Form ADV can be found here https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/151197
Important Disclosures
Exchange Traded Concepts is an SEC Registered Investment Adviser. The Firm's Form ADV is publicly available and can be found here: https://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/Firm/151197. ETC may be subject to various conflicts of interest in the provision of its services. Potential conflicts of interest shall be identified in the Firm's Form ADV. The Exchange Traded Funds are referred to as "Funds" for purposes of this document. ETC transacts business in the United States and other jurisdictions where it is properly registered or excluded or exempted from registration requirements. This document does not constitute an offer of services in jurisdictions where ETC does not have the necessary licenses.
No representation is made that any Fund's investment process, objectives, goals or risk management techniques will or are likely to be achieved or be successful or that any Fund or any underlying investment will make any profit or will not sustain losses. The risks of investing in a Fund will not be negated by ETC's Fund services, and no assurance is given that a Fund will not be exposed to risks of significant trading losses.
The information provided herein does not constitute tax, legal or accounting advice. ETC does not provide legal, financial, accounting or tax advice. Clients and prospective Clients, as well as investors and prospective investors in a Fund ("Investors") are advised to seek the counsel of their own legal, financial and tax advisors for all matters relating to the services and structures contemplated herein. Each Investor (either alone or with its professional advisors) is solely responsible for its own due diligence, risk assessment and tolerance, investment objectives, any decision to invest in a Fund, and for monitoring its investment for purposes of determining whether it wishes to remain invested in such product and whether such product continues to be appropriate for its circumstances and requirements.
The information provided herein: (a) is provided as of the date indicated, (b) is in summary only and is not complete, and (c) is subject to change at any time without notice. Certain information provided by ETC is based on third-party sources and, although generally believed to be reliable, has not been independently verified. ETC is not responsible for errors or omissions from these sources. No representation is made with respect to the accuracy, completeness, or timeliness of such information, and ETC assumes no obligation to update or otherwise revise such information. In no event will ETC be liable to any party for any direct, indirect, incidental, exemplary, compensatory, punitive, special or consequential damages, costs, expenses, legal fees or losses (including, without limitation, lost income or lost profits and opportunity costs) in connection with the use of the information contained herein, even if advised of the possibility of such damages. ETC and its respective employees and its affiliates hereby exclude, to the extent permitted by applicable law, all liability in connection with the use of the information herein.
Interests in Funds will not be insured by the FDIC, the SIPC or any other organization, will not be deposits of any bank, and are not guaranteed by any bank.